For a night out in New York City with fiancé Benny Blanco, Gomez stepped out in a monochromatic makeup combo. Lightly blended across the singer’s eyelids was a layer of coral-toned eyeshadow that stopped abruptly at the outer corner—along with a sharp and thin cat eye.

The music producer went for his typical loud look while Gomez stayed true to a monochromatic and understated outfit.